To What Extent Does Overprotective Parenting Lead to Adolescent Depression? A Cultural Perspective

0
258

Abstract

There has been a rise in adolescent mental health problems in recent years. One of the common causes of depression and anxiety in teenagers is often overprotective or strict authoritarian parenting styles. Overprotective parenting is characterized by excessive psychological  and  behavioral  control  of  their  children.  This parenting style is  similar  to  authoritarian parenting with the difference being that authoritarian parents tend not to show  warmth.  In  examining  this  problem  from  a  cultural  perspective,  the  research project  investigated,  “To  what   extent  does  overprotective   parenting  lead  to   adolescent depression? “ A survey was distributed to adolescents in the US and China. There were 36 participants between the ages of 16 and 26+. The study found that participants that had overprotective and authoritarian styles of parenting tended to  have more conflicts with their parents, did worse academically,  had  little  social  life,  felt  it  was  difficult  to  have  friends,  as  well  as  they  lost confidence in dating, or they needed to date who their parents wanted. With reference to mental health, more participants experienced anxiety as opposed to depression and most coped by listening to music,talking with friends and engaging in sports as a way to overcome their tension and distress. Culture did not play a role, surprisingly, but rather the style of parenting.

Introduction

Adolescence is a time of great change for young people. During adolescence, individuals gain more independence and take on more responsibilities as they try to navigate the complexities of adult life which for some causes mental health difficulties.  Globally it is estimated that 1 in 10 adolescents suffer from a mental disorder1. In America, 15 % of teenagers suffer from depression, the highest rate of all the mental health disorders2. Some of the symptoms that adolescents experience when they have depression are persistent sadness, loss of interest, changes in appetite and sleep patterns, fatigue, difficulty

concentrating, feelings of worthlessness, and even thoughts of death or suicide3. Thus, understanding the causes of depression is important.

There  are  multiple  reasons  adolescents  experience  depression  including  hormonal  changes, genetic predisposition, family history of mental health conditions, high levels of  stress (such as academic pressure or social challenges), traumatic experiences, bullying, feelings of social isolation, body image issues, substance abuse, and underlying medical  conditions4. Relationships with their parents because of  their parenting styles also can cause depression in teenagers as they try to negotiate  more freedom and independence which may cause more conflicts .

One type of parenting style that has been found to cause depression is overprotective parenting.  Overprotective  parenting  is  characterized  by  excessive  psychological  and behavioral  control  of  their  children5.  Overprotective  parenting  can  be expressed differently in different cultures. It’s especially difficult when teenagers move to a more liberal country and find that other adolescents have more freedoms, yet perhaps they, themselves, have more restrictions than the cultural norms of the country they are now  living  in  because  of  expectations  of  their  cultural  background.  Depression  that results from  not  being  able  to  find  a  balance  between  their  parents  and their own expectations due to cultural norms is an important area to research.

Therefore,  this   research  project  will   explore:  To  what   extent  does  overprotective parenting lead to adolescent depression? A Cultural Perspective.The study will address the following objectives: Examine the impact of cultural expectations on adolescents’ perceptions of parental control; analyze the correlation between overprotective parenting and adolescent depression under different cultures; and investigate how adolescents cope with mental health challenges due to overprotective parenting.

Literature Review

This literature will explore studies that investigate the relationship between adolescent depression and parenting styles, with an emphasis on overprotective parenting and the role of culture.

Adolescent Depression

Adolescent depression is a mental health problem which causes teenagers to feel frustrated and lose interest in everyday life. Globally, around 14% teenagers from  10 to 19 suffered mental disorders, and depression is one of the main contributors6. The rate of depression among adolescents aged 10- 14 was 1. 1%, with an increase to 2.8% among adolescents aged 15- 19. Adolescent depression may cause an abrupt and  unpredictable  shift  in  teenager’s  mood,  which  can  affect  teenagers’  academic performance and social interactions negatively6. Researchers suggest that these rates are closer to 13%, similar to those in countries where more young people access mental health services. Young people in less developed countries are diagnosed less because they have less access to affordable services. Only young people that have been diagnosed and received mental health services can be accessed for research. The estimate, therefore, is presumed to be higher6.

Parenting Styles

Parenting styles have been known to cause distress in young people. There are four types of parenting, including authoritarian parenting, permissive parenting, authoritative (democratic) parenting, and uninvolved parenting7.

Parenting StyleCharacteristicsEffects on Teenagers
Authoritarian ParentingRigid rules enforced with punishmentLittle warmth or emotional supportNo room for negotiation or discussionMore obedient or anxiousMore rebelliousLower Self-Esteem
Permissive Parentingfew rules or  structureparents act more as friendsminimal disciplineLacks self disciplineBecomes impulsive
Authoritative (Democratic) ParentingClear expectations and rulesWarm, encouraging independenceOpen communicationMore confidentBetter social and academic performanceGood communication skills
Uninvolved ParentingNeglectfulLittle emotional supportDifficult managing emotions

Overprotective Parenting & Culture

The following international studies explore the effect of overprotective parenting styles from youth in the Netherlands, Belgium, Malaysia, China, India, Middle Eastern and Latin American backgrounds, South Africa and the Philippines.

In  a  study  by  Mousavi  et.al 8,  researchers  explored  the  relationship  between perceived   parenting   styles   and    anxiety   among   culturally   different   adolescents. Researchers provided questionnaires to 227 students aged from 13 to 18 from different cultural backgrounds such as Malaysia, China, India, Middle Eastern and white origins to measure parenting styles  and  anxiety  symptoms.They found  cultural  differences  happened  in parenting  styles  and  anxiety,  especially  between  Caucasians  and  non-Caucasians. There were significant differences in anxiety symptoms among the five cultural groups.

RegionAnxiety Symptoms
Europe and Americafewest anxiety symptoms reported
asianhigher levels of anxiety symptoms
Culture GroupEmotional WarmthAnxious/Overprotective Parenting
Chinese Adolescentslowest reported emotional warmthHigh levels of anxious rearing
Malaysian AdolescentsMore emotional warmth than Chinese adolescentsHigher levels of anxious reading than Chinese adolescents
Indian AdolescentsMore emotional warmth compared to Chinese & Malaysian teensLess anxious parenting compared to Malaysian adolescents
Arab AdolescentsHigher levels of emotional warmth than Chinese adolescentsHigher level of overcontrol/overprotective parenting
Cultural GroupPredictor of Anxiety
Chinese AdolescentsAnxious rearing
Malaysian AdolescentsParental rejection
Indian AdolescentsOverprotective parenting
European & American AdolescentsOverprotective parenting
Arab AdolescentsOverprotective parenting

This study indicates that if parents are overprotective, adolescents are more likely to have internalizing problems (like depression or anxiety) and antisocial behavior (hurting others) and may exhibit lower academic achievement. Whether adolescents perceive their parents as warm and rejecting matters too. If parents are not only overprotective but also display warm and caring behaviors, then this caring may help to mitigate the negative effects of overprotection; However, apathy may exacerbate the negative effects of overprotection89.

In a study by Arslan et al9the aim was to explore the effects of maternal and paternal overprotection on adolescent development and examined differences that may result from parental gender differences. The procedure was to use data from the Dutch Trials  cohort  study,  which  included  a  questionnaire  and  interview  data  from  young people 11, 13 and 16 years of age that were analyzed. The participants were a sample of  2,229  adolescents  from  five  municipalities  in  the  northern  Netherlands.  Findings showed  that   perceived  maternal  and   paternal  overprotection  was   associated  with increased internalizing problems and decreased prosocial behavior in adolescents. This association was  more  pronounced  between  the  ages  of  11  and  16.  Regarding  the affection shown by parents, there was no gender difference found. This means it did not matter which gender of the parent was overprotective, because the overprotective style

made young  people feel  anxious  or depressed with  less  positive  behaviors  towards others.

In  a  study  by  Flamant  et.al 10,the  researchers  explored  how  adolescents  with  overprotective  parents coped with their developmental  issues  and the  role that their  coping strategies play in regulating the relationship between parental overprotection and  maladjustment. The  data was  collected  and  analyzed  using  a  moderation-mediation  model. The conclusion is that  family-based interventions targeting adolescents’ coping responses may improve their psychosocial adjustment and  the relationship between parents and adolescents.

The similarities between Netherlands and Belgiums shows below.

CategoryThe NetherlandsBelgium
Sample Size2229 adolescents (ages 11, 13 and 16) from 5 municipalities382 adolescents (approximately 17 years old)
Impact of Overprotective ParentingBoth maternal and paternal overprotection associated with increased internalizing problems and reduced prosocial behaviorOverprotective parenting linked to developmental problems and psychological frustration
Coping Mechanismsno specific focus on coping mechanismscoping responses like compulsive compliance worsened developmental issues, negotiation played a protective role
Parent Gender impactno gender difference in the impact of maternal vs paternal overprotectionmaternal overprotection influenced outcomes. There is no parental influence comparison.
Age Groupadolescents aged 11-16 were most affected by parental overprotectionadolescents around 17 years old faced similar issues from overprotection

According to this comparison chart, there are some similarities and differences of overprotectiveness under different cultural backgrounds. The similarities is that overprotective parenting style is related to developmental problems including anxiety in both countries. The differences are the coping mechanisms used by the two adolescents groups, and it seems the confrontation between parents and children can make developmental issues worse, while communication can alleviate them.

The study was conducted by Van Petegem11 explored the relationship between adolescents’ perceptions of the co-parental relationship which is how parents interact with each other in their parental role and overprotective parenting. The researchers hypothesized that overprotective parenting would be linked to higher levels of anxiety symptoms in adolescents. There were 174 Swiss adolescents participants who were around 17 years old, and 73% of them were girls. In this study, the participants were asked  to  fill  out  questionnaires  to  assess  their  perceptions  of  the  co-parental relationship.  In  conclusion,  the  researchers  found  that  overprotective  parenting  is positively correlated with the anxiety level of teenagers.

In this cross-sectional study conducted by Ullmann et al12, the researchers tried to explore the potential link between the overprotective parenting style and how it affects children’s disease burden. Well, the main objective was to gain a deeper understanding of the origins and consequences of intergenerational psychological trauma. The study involved 40 healthy students as participants, and the findings indicated that both hair cortisol  levels  and  overprotective  parenting  were  reliable  indicators  for  diagnosing TSRD (Trauma and Stressor-Related Disorders).   This  shows  that although  parents might  think  that  being  overprotective  protects  their  children,  it  can  actually  create trauma.

Parental characteristics, such as their gender and mental health, were explored in the next two studies in relation to their parenting styles and effect on their teenage children. In a study conducted by Piko & Balazs13, researchers in Hungary examined the impact  of  authoritative  parenting  style  and  other  family  factors  like  negative  family interactions and  positive  parental  identification,  on  adolescent  depressive  symptoms.

Here are the gender differences in parental influence on Depressive Symptoms.

Factorboysgirls
parenting style and depressionAuthoritative parenting negatively associated with mood problemsAuthoritative parenting negatively associated with mood problems, stronger effect on girls
maternal responsivenessgreater positive effect on reducing depression in boysless significant impact on girls’ depression
parental responsivenessless significant impact on boys’ depressionstrong positive effect on reducing depression in girls
maternal demandingnesspositively correlated with boys’ depressionpositively correlated with girls’ depression
parenteral demandingnessless significant impact on boys’ depressionstrong positive correlation with girls’ depression

This study indicated the similarities and differences on both genders when they cope with authoritative parenting style. Authoritative parenting has a negative association with both genders, but the impact on the girls is stronger. Maternal responsiveness had a stronger positive effect on reducing depression in boys than they did in girls. This means that boys may benefit more from maternal attention than girls when experiencing high maternal responsiveness. General parental responsiveness had a stronger effect on reducing depression for girls than boys. This suggests that girls have a broader emotional attachment or expectations towards both parents. Maternal demandingness is positively associated with depression in both boys and girls, referring that excessive pressure from mothers lead to higher levels of stress and depression to children from both genders. The more positive association between paternal demandingness and depression in girls than boys suggests that girls are more sensitive to their fathers’ expectations than boys are.

In a study by Morales & Torres14, the researchers examined the potential link between parental psychopathology, psychosocial stress, and the manifestation of overprotective  parenting  behaviors.  The   researchers  invited  64  Latino  parents  as  participants.   Psychosocial   stress,   psychopathology,   and   overprotective   parenting  behaviors were measured through completed questionnaires from parents. The study  utilized regression analyses to investigate the factors predicting overprotective parenting, which encompassed control, supervision, and separation-related concerns. Researchers  found that, due to immigration-related stress, Latino parents used controlling parenting  styles.   This    shows   that    external    factors   on    parents’    lives   that    affect    their  psychopathology can influence their parenting style.

Race also can be a factor affecting parenting styles. Muris et.al15 investigated  DSM-defined anxiety  symptoms  in  adolescents  from  South  Africa. The  researchers  collected data from 701 children and adolescents, of which 334 were boys and 367  were girls, ages 8 to 18 years old from primary schools near Stellenbosch, South Africa.

 Cultural GroupAnxiety LevelsParenting Styles Linked to Anxiety
White YouthLower anxiety levels compared to colored youthless impact from anxious rearing, overprotection, and rejection
Colored Youthhigher anxiety levelsAnxious rearing, overprotection, and rejection

According to the data, white youth report lower levels of anxiety than colored youth. This difference reflects broader societal factors and challenges faced by the colored youth, such as economic disparities, social status, or historical inequalities, which contribute to higher levels of anxiety to colored youth. Anxious rearting, overprotection, and rejection had little effect on anxiety levels among white youth. This suggests that even if white adolescents are exposed to these less supportive parenting styles, they may have more external resources, including better access to mental health care, education, or community support, to buffer against the negative effects of this parenting. However, colored youth have higher levels of anxiety when they are exposed to anxious rearing, overprotection, and rejection. This is because colored youth face more external stressors on average than white youth, including socioeconomic challenges or racial discrimination, which can amplify the effects of negative parenting.

Based on the study conducted by Ganaprakasam et.al16, researchers investigated how helicopter parenting affected psychological well-being and self-efficacy for learning among adolescents. Helicopter parenting, the colloquial term of overprotective parenting, refers to a style of parenting where parents exhibit overprotective behaviors in a highly controlling way (Omer et.al, 2016). The study involved 96 adolescents aged from fifteen to seventeen, who were selected from a community-based catechism school located in the northern part of Peninsular Malaysia. The participants filled in the Helicopter Parenting

Questionnaire, the General Health Questionnaire, and a self-efficacy for learning scale. The findings of the research revealed that there was a negative correlation between the overprotective parenting style and the overall well-being of adolescents.

Furthermore, the study highlighted the harmful effects of helicopter parenting on adolescents’ self-efficacy for learning. It will be a challenge for the children who are raised by helicopter parents to excessively rely on external guidance and evaluation to learn independently and confidently.

The   study   by   Gere   et.al  17   aimed   to   examine   the   relationship   between overprotective parenting and child anxiety, and consider co-occurring behavior problems at the same time.  In this  study, there were  190  children  (aged  7-13,  89  boys),  171 mothers, and 135 fathers as participants to elevated child internalizing symptoms. The researchers collected data from “Anxiety Disorder Interview Schedule for DSM-IV, Child and Parent versions” , “Child Behavior Checklist” , and “Rearing Behavior Questionnaire”. The research revealed that once the co-occurring child behavior symptoms were taken into  account,  the  significant  correlation  previously  observed  between  overprotective parenting  and  child  anxiety  symptoms  vanished.  This  indicates  that  overprotective parenting might not be the only direct factor linked to child anxiety. It appears that the connection  between  child  anxiety  symptoms  and  overprotective  parenting  could  be explained  by  the  presence  of  simultaneous  child  behavior  problems,  indicating  how children’s  behaviors  affect  parenting  and  how  parenting  styles  can  affect  children’s behaviors.

Attachment styles were explored in this next study and the impact of their parenting style after children  leave  home.  A study investigated  why  parents  tend  to  adopt  an excessively  protective  parenting  style  during  interactions  with  their  approaching  adulthood children.  Specifically,  they  explored  the  correlations   between   parental  attachment  styles (maternal and paternal attachment anxiety and avoidance), parental separation anxiety, and parental  overprotectiveness.  Additionally,  they  examined  whether   maternal   attachment, separation anxiety, and overprotectiveness can predict the real-life situation of emerging adults one year later (living at home or away from home), as well as the adverse effects of maternal overprotectiveness on their departure. The study involved 246 white adolescents in their final year of high school, along with their  parents,  including 242  mothers and 218 fathers. The average  age  of  the   participants was   17.14  years.   Data  was  collected  from participants through a questionnaire survey to assess parental attachment styles, separation anxiety, and overprotection.  Findings showed that  parental  attachment anxiety  is  positively associated with elevated separation anxiety and heightened parental overprotection. Maternal attachment  anxiety  is  correlated  with  paternal  separation  anxiety,  and  both  are  linked  to maternal overprotection, demonstrating significant partner effects. Maternal separation anxiety directly corresponds to more adverse impacts when children leave home. Moreover, increased maternal overprotection is connected to a higher probability of children residing at home one year later and experiencing more negative effects during the leaving process.

In summary, these studies show that external factors such as culture, race, external political situations,  gender  of   parents,  together  with   internal  factors   such  as  attachment  styles, psychopathology of parents  and internalized beliefs about parenting styles all can affect the mental health of adolescents as they try to gain independence and develop their identity during this stage of their development. These studies helped to inform how this research study was designed.

Methodology

The research design included developing a quantitative survey to young people 16 years old and older on August 1st, 2023. The study used two ways to collect the answers, spreading the survey via instagram, and some people forwarded this survey on their own accounts, so more and more people from different groups answered this survey. Researchers also put this survey on an employment website to pay for the answers. Researchers took out one survey result after figuring out there are some inconsistencies in that result, and that result was considered invalid.Fourteen questions were developed that asked questions related to parenting styles, the level of freedom people had as teenagers to

direct their lives and the impact of those parenting styles on their friendships, personal relationships, academic achievement, how they coped, and whether they would use the same parenting style with their own children in the future. The pie chart at the top is the seven people from instagram, and the one below is the 29 participants from the employment website.

Participants

Participants were 27% males and 70.3 % females; 2.7% of people responded non-binary.




Participants came from various cultures: 86.4 % were of Asian background,  10.8% were North American, and 2.7% were from African cultural backgrounds.

All the participants from the employment website are Chinese people.


The ages of participants were varied. 24.3% who were 16-18 years old,16.2% were between the ages of 19-21, 32.4% were 22-25 and 24.3% were between 26-28 years old.


Results

How could you describe the parenting style of growing up?

How has the parenting style affected you?

How did your parenting style cause your distress?

How did your parenting style affect your friendship?

How did your parenting style affect your academic achievement?

Did your parents’ style of parenting influence your future goals and plans about work or education?

Did their parenting styles affect your romantic relationships?

How did you cope when you did not agree or like their parenting style?

To what extent was your parents’ parenting style influenced by their culture?

Do you think that parenting rules are more strict in your culture in comparison to other cultures?

If you are living abroad, outside of your own country, to what extent are your parents more overprotective?

If you are living abroad, do you feel there are big differences in the cultural values that cause distress because your parents are overprotective?

 If /when you have children, will you have the same parenting styles as your parents?

If you answered no, what would you change?

Discussion

This  research  explored,  “ To  what  extent  does  overprotective  parenting  lead  to  adolescent  depression?A Cultural Perspective.” An examination of participant responses that indicated that  they  experienced  overprotective  but  warm  parenting  styles  (37.8%)  and  authoritarian-strict,  controlling parenting styles (16.2%) are compared in relation to the quality of their mental health. Overprotective parenting was examined in relation to the degree that participants’ mental health  was affected as a result of the degree of conformity or conflict that they had with their parents’ expectations, quality of friendships and romantic relationships, academic achievement, cultural  values and coping skills.

Similar findings from Flamant et.al18, findings showed that those with overprotective parents  and  authoritarian   parenting  styles,  experienced   more  conflicts  with  their   parents (37.8 %) than those from more permissive parenting styles and those that were compliant with their parents expectations suffered more mental health effects such as anxiety or depression.

Participants’  mental  health was also affected  if overprotective  parenting affected their social social  life. The  research found that those with overprotective  parents experienced  less of a social life, felt it was difficult to have friends as well as lost confidence in dating, or they needed to date who their parents wanted. Those with authoritarian parenting styles experienced better relationships with friends even though they too  lacked confidence in dating. This could be due to their young age and inexperience with romantic relationships.This could possibly also be a result of a finding by Arslan9 that suggests that overprotective parenting can make young people  feel  anxious  or  depressed  with  less  positive  behaviors  towards  others  which  may interfere with developing positive relationships.

The research found that those with overprotective parents and authoritarian parents were less successful academically as they felt more anxious about attaining high academic achievement. Some did  not  care whether they  met  their  parents  expectations for good grades and were unmotivated. This shows that both strict controlling parenting and overprotective parenting can have  a  negative  effect  on  academic  achievement  as  suggested  also  by  the  findings   by Ganaprakasam  et.al 16  who  found  that  “helicopter  parenting” ,  a  form  of  overprotective parenting  prevents children from gaining confidence in their learning ability.

With respect to tension between one’s cultural values and that of the host country if they lived abroad, the research found that those with overprotective parents and authoritarian parenting styles didn’t have a significant tension due to a clash of cultural values.

Young  people  with  both  overprotective  and  authoritarian  parenting  styles  used  music  to escape as a coping mechanism, as well as talking to friends and engaging in sports.

In answering the research question, results of this study showed that both overprotective and authoritarian parenting styles can cause depression but also anxiety in young people. This appeared to be true across cultures of participants. The parenting style was the primary factor on young people’s mental health and not culture. This means that no matter what culture the parents come from, if they raise their children in an authoritative way or an overprotective way, similar negative psychological effects will happen under all cultural backgrounds. Therefore, the root cause of mental health problems often can be traced back to the power imbalance in parenting styles rather than cultural differences. Finally, under globalization of today, parenting styles are spreading across cultural boundaries. Modern parents rely on scientific and psychological research to guide their parenting practices more and more. As a result, culture was not the key factor in this process. Therefore, instead of attributing anxiety and depression problems to cultural differences, it is better to focus on how to improve parenting styles, enhance children’s autonomy and emotional support, and thus improve their mental health.

The majority of participants said that they would not repeat their parent’s overprotective parenting  style.  Future  research  may  examine  how  the  children  of  overprotective  parents actually parent their children.

Finally, This study also has one limitation, the lack of exploration of the potential for a two-way relationship between parenting style and adolescent behavior. This study focuses on how overprotective parenting can lead to increased anxiety in adolescents, but it does not talk a lot about how adolescents’ coping mechanisms influence parental control in turn. The future research can track how parenting styles and adolescent behavior interact in a bidirectional way and how they change over time. The future research can also track if parents are aware of their overprotectiveness and how they justify it under different cultural contexts. Additionally, the future researchers should consider more to the intersection of socioeconomic status and culture, taking into account variables such as income, education, and access to resources. This can further clarify whether socioeconomic inequalities or the racial differences lead to anxiety and parenting instead of cultural factors.

Conclusion

In conclusion, there are many factors affecting the mental health of young people. However, one of those factors has to do with parenting styles. While parents try to protect their children, they actually prevent them from building confidence in their ability to manage their lives. Holding young people back creates frustration, sadness and anxiety because they cannot change their situation  which  affects  their  lives,  such  as  their  academic  achievement,  ability  to  maintain friendships and relationships and even plan for the future that they want which may not be the same as their parents expectations. Young people that have better coping skills use music, sports and talking to others that they can have access to. However, some use substances that create greater problems for their lives. As adolescence is a time of growth and independence, it would be helpful for parents to have support so they can communicate better with their children. School is a good place to offer this support as parents will more likely go to events hosted by the school such as parenting evenings, whereas they might not seek support from outside help because they might not feel they are doing anything wrong. If parents are supported and taught how to respond to their children, then they will not need to be so strict, but learn to develop trust that their children can make good decisions.

References

  1. WHO: Global Mental Health Estimates. World Health Organization: https://www.who.int/data/global-health-estimates []
  2. CDC Teen Mental Health. (2023). Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Mental Health | DASH | CDC .https://www.cdc.gov/healthyyouth/mental-health/index.htm []
  3. Mayo Clinic.(2022). Teen Depression: Accessed: https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/teen-depression/symptoms-causes/syc-20350985 []
  4. Bruce, D. (2022).Teen Depression: Causes, Symptoms, Heredity, and Treatments. Blog. Web MD. https://www.webmd.com/depression/teen-depression []
  5. Arzt.(2023). “Overprotective Parents: Signs, Examples, & Effects on Mental Health.”ChoosingTherapy.Com, www.choosingtherapy.com/overprotective-parents/ []
  6. WHO: Global Mental Health Estimates. World Health Organization: https://www.who.int/data/global-health-estimates [] [] []
  7. Sanvictores.(2022). “Types of Parenting Styles and Effects on Children.” StatPearls [Internet]., U.S. National Library of Medicine, www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK568743/ []
  8. Mousavi, S. E., Low, W. Y., & Hashim, A. H. (2016). Perceived parenting styles and cultural influences in adolescent’s anxiety: A cross-cultural comparison. Journal of Child and Family Studies, 25(7), 2102–2110. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10826-016-0393-x [] []
  9. Arslan, İ. B., Lucassen, N., Keijsers, L., & Stevens, G. W. J. M. (2023). When Too Much Help is of No Help: Mothers’ and Fathers’ Perceived Overprotective Behavior and (Mal)Adaptive Functioning in Adolescents. Journal of youth and adolescence, 52(5), 1010–1023. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10964-022-01723-0 [] [] []
  10. Flamant, N., Boncquet, M., Van Petegem, S., Haerens, L., Beyers, W., & Soenens, B. (2022). To endure or to resist? Adolescents’ coping with overprotective parenting. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, 82, 101444.101444, ISSN 0193-3973, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.appdev.2022.101444 []
  11. Van Petegem, S., Albert Sznitman, G., Darwiche, J., & Zimmermann, G. (2022). Putting parental overprotection into a family systems context: Relations of overprotective parenting with perceived coparenting and adolescent anxiety. Family process, 61(2), 792-807.https://doi.org/10.1111/famp.12709 []
  12. Ullmann, E., Licinio, J., Barthel, A., Petrowski, K., Stalder, T., Bornstein, S. R., & Kirschbaum, C. (2017). Persistent LHPA activation in German individuals raised in an overprotective parental behavior. Scientific reports, 7(1), 2778.https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-017-01718-z []
  13. Piko, B. F., & Balázs, M. Á. (2012). Control or involvement? Relationship between authoritative parenting style and adolescent depressive symptomatology. European child & adolescent psychiatry, 21, 149-155.https://doi.org/10.1007/s00787-012-0246-0 []
  14. Suarez‐Morales, L., & Torres, C. (2021). Understanding the factors associated with overprotective parenting behaviors in Latino parents. Family Relations, 70(5), 1556-1570.https://doi.org/10.1111/fare.12548 []
  15. Muris, P., Loxton, H., Neumann, A., du Plessis, M., King, N., & Ollendick, T. (2006). DSM-defined anxiety disorders symptoms in South African youths: Their assessment and relationship with perceived parental rearing behaviors. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 44(6), 883-896.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.brat.2005.06.002 []
  16. Ganaprakasam, C., Davaidass, K. S., & Muniandy, S. C. (2018). Helicopter parenting and psychological consequences among adolescent. International Journal of Scientific and Research Publications, 8(6), 378-382.DOI: 10.29322/IJSRP .8.6.2018.p7848 [] []
  17. Gere, M. K., Villabø, M. A., Torgersen, S., & Kendall, P. C. (2012). Overprotective parenting and child anxiety: The role of co-occurring child behavior problems. Journal of anxiety disorders, 26(6), 642- 649.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.janxdis.2012.04.003 []
  18. Flamant, N., Boncquet, M., Van Petegem, S., Haerens, L., Beyers, W., & Soenens, B. (2022). To endure or to resist? Adolescents’ coping with overprotective parenting. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, 82, 101444.101444, ISSN 0193-3973, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.appdev.2022.101444 []

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here